New Delhi, India: The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023, India’s ambitious overhaul of its criminal code, is facing its first major public backlash over Clause 2 of Section 106. This provision prescribes a steep sentence of up to 10 years imprisonment and a fine for drivers involved in fatal accidents who flee the scene. While intended to curb hit-and-run cases, it has triggered widespread protests from truck drivers, concerns from legal experts, and a heated national debate on road safety and criminal justice reform.
Truck drivers protest
Truck drivers, a key economic backbone of India, have taken to the streets in recent weeks, fearing the harsh penalties could unfairly ensnare them in situations beyond their control. They argue that accidents often occur in remote areas with limited communication, forcing them to seek help elsewhere before reporting. Additionally, concerns have been raised about the vagueness of the term “soon after the incident”, leaving room for arbitrary interpretation and potential misuse.
Legal experts warn
Legal experts have also voiced concerns about due process, emphasizing the need for investigations and fair trials before imposing such severe punishments. They warn that the provision could lead to false accusations and wrongful convictions, especially against vulnerable groups like truck drivers.
Proponents disagree
However, proponents of the provision argue that the stringent penalty is necessary to deter hit-and-run cases, which often leave families of victims devastated and seeking justice. They point to rampant road accidents in India, claiming that existing laws haven’t been effective enough.
Government balancing act
The government, caught in the crossfire, has sought to placate both sides. While assuring truck drivers that the provision won’t be misapplied, they are also holding consultations to potentially clarify its language. This balancing act underscores the complexities of balancing public safety with individual rights within a comprehensive criminal justice system.
Lessons learned
The BNS 2023’s hit-and-run controversy offers a microcosm of India’s larger grapple with legal reform. It reminds us that even well-intentioned laws can have unintended consequences if not carefully crafted and implemented. As the debate unfolds, India must find a way to ensure road safety without compromising justice and the rights of its citizens. Only then can this new legal framework truly deliver its promise of a fairer and more just society.
Follow us on Facebook, X, YouTube & Instagram to never miss an update from The Credible India